Within Demi Lovato
Did the Ghost Device Really Answer Lovato?
The Carmen sequence turned ambiguous device responses into a comic ghost story without showing that the equipment detected any entity.
On this page
- How the Carmen exchange unfolded
- What paranormal devices claim to detect
- Why ambiguous signals create persuasive stories
Page outline Jump by section
Introduction
One of the most discussed moments in Unidentified with Demi Lovato takes place not during a UFO sighting but inside an allegedly haunted building at Vulture City, Arizona. In the second episode, The Star People, Demi Lovato and paranormal investigators interpret responses from ghost-hunting equipment as communication from a female spirit they call “Carmen”. The sequence culminates in Lovato singing to the supposed spirit after concluding that it was uncomfortable around men because of past trauma. The scene became widely shared online, but its significance lies less in any demonstrated paranormal evidence than in how ambiguous electronic signals were woven into a compelling narrative.[@peacocktv]peacocktv.comOpen source on peacocktv.com.
The Vulture City investigation illustrates a recurring feature of paranormal television: devices produce simple, open-ended signals, while investigators supply the interpretation. Rather than showing equipment conclusively detecting an entity, the programme presents a series of assumptions that gradually develop into a coherent ghost story.
How the Carmen exchange unfolded
Episode two takes the team to Vulture City, an abandoned Arizona mining settlement promoted as a location associated with ghosts, UFOs and unexplained experiences. The stated purpose is to explore whether there might be a connection between extraterrestrials and hauntings rather than to investigate a single ghost claim in isolation.[@peacocktv]peacocktv.comOpen source on peacocktv.com.
Inside an abandoned building, paranormal investigator Chris Smith uses electronic ghost-hunting equipment while asking questions directed at an unseen presence. At various points, audible responses from the device are treated as meaningful answers.
The exchange develops through several interpretive steps:
- Initial device responses are taken to indicate that an unseen presence is present.
- The investigators identify that presence as a woman they call “Carmen”.
- When some questions receive no apparent response, the lack of activity is interpreted as reluctance rather than absence.
- Smith suggests the entity may dislike the men in the room.
- After the men temporarily leave, further beeps are interpreted as confirming that explanation.
- Lovato empathises with the supposed spirit, discussing shared experiences of trauma before singing part of Skyscraper.
By the end of the sequence, what began as isolated electronic signals has become a detailed narrative involving personality, emotional history and interpersonal preferences. None of those characteristics are directly measured by the equipment itself; they emerge through conversation and interpretation. Reports describing the scene note that the group viewed the final response after Lovato sang as equivalent to applause or approval.[Breitbart]breitbart.comWatch: Demi Lovato Serenades Ghost Suffering from Sexism-Induced TraumaWatch: Demi Lovato Serenades Ghost Suffering from Sexism-Induced TraumaDecember 24, 2021…
What paranormal devices claim to detect
The Carmen sequence relies on equipment commonly used in paranormal investigations, particularly electromagnetic field (EMF) meters or similar electronic detectors.
Manufacturers and paranormal investigators often describe these devices as tools that can register changes in electromagnetic fields or disturbances that they believe may accompany spirit activity. In television investigations, an audible tone or flashing light is frequently treated as a “yes” response during questioning.
From a scientific perspective, however, these instruments do not detect ghosts. EMF meters are designed to measure electromagnetic fields produced by electrical wiring, appliances, radios, mobile phones and many other ordinary environmental sources. Changes in readings demonstrate only that electromagnetic conditions have changed—not why they changed.
The Carmen investigation illustrates this distinction. Viewers observe the equipment producing responses, but the programme offers no independent method of establishing that:
- a conscious entity caused the readings;
- the responses corresponded to the questions being asked;
- alternative environmental explanations were excluded; or
- the same results could be reproduced under controlled conditions.
Consequently, the equipment provides observable events—the lights or sounds—but not direct evidence that those events originated from a ghost.
Why ambiguous signals become persuasive stories
The effectiveness of the Carmen scene depends less on technology than on storytelling.
The device produces only limited information: a tone, light or brief activation. Human participants then transform that limited information into an increasingly detailed account through interpretation.
Several psychological mechanisms make this process compelling:
- Pattern recognition. People naturally search for meaningful relationships between events, especially when questions and responses occur close together.
- Confirmation bias. Once investigators begin to suspect a particular explanation, later signals are more readily interpreted as supporting that interpretation.
- Narrative completion. Audiences generally find complete stories more satisfying than unexplained observations, encouraging investigators to fill informational gaps.
- Emotional engagement. Lovato’s discussion of trauma creates empathy that shifts attention away from evaluating the device itself and towards the human story being told.
Importantly, none of these mechanisms requires deception. Participants may sincerely believe their interpretations while reaching conclusions that extend beyond what the equipment objectively demonstrates.
Did the ghost device really answer Lovato?
Based on what is shown in the episode, the answer is no in any demonstrable sense.
The programme records electronic responses occurring during questioning, but it does not establish that the equipment is communicating with an intelligent entity. The conclusion that “Carmen” answered particular questions depends entirely on investigators assigning meaning to ambiguous signals.
The episode therefore presents several layers of inference:
- A device activates.
- The activation is assumed to indicate a nearby presence.
- The presence is assumed to be a particular individual.
- Subsequent activations are interpreted as specific answers.
- Those answers are used to infer personality, emotional history and motivations.
Each stage requires interpretation beyond the observable behaviour of the device itself.
This distinction explains why the Carmen scene became memorable. It is not because viewers witnessed clear evidence that ghost-hunting equipment identified or communicated with a spirit, but because a series of uncertain electronic responses evolved into a vivid emotional encounter between Lovato and an unseen character.
Why the scene stands out within the series
Within Unidentified with Demi Lovato, the Vulture City sequence marks a shift from investigating unidentified aerial phenomena towards blending UFO beliefs with broader paranormal traditions. Rather than treating ghosts and extraterrestrials as separate subjects, the episode explores them as potentially connected mysteries.[@peacocktv]peacocktv.comOpen source on peacocktv.com.
The Carmen scene also became one of the programme’s most widely circulated moments because it combined celebrity, humour and emotional sincerity. Years later, Lovato reflected on the now-viral sequence with amusement, acknowledging the circumstances in which it was filmed while maintaining a broader belief in paranormal phenomena.[People.com]people.comThe show, which aired on Peacock, chronicles Lovato's explorations into UFOs and the paranormal alongside friends Mathew Scott Montgomery…
As a case study, the episode is less significant for what it demonstrates about ghosts than for what it reveals about paranormal television. The ghost-hunting equipment does not independently establish communication with an entity. Instead, the dramatic impact comes from the investigators’ interpretation of ambiguous signals, transforming simple electronic responses into a memorable story centred on “Carmen”.
Amazon book picks
Further Reading
Books and field guides related to Did the Ghost Device Really Answer Lovato?. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.
Spook: Science Tackles the Afterlife
The author looks to science to determine whether the human soul exists in death, and travels to various places around the world to discus...
Paranormality: Why We See What Isn't There
'People are emotionally drawn to the supernatural. They actively want weird, spooky things to be true . . . Wiseman shows us a higher joy...
The Believing Brain
"A wonderfully lucid, accessible, and wide-ranging account of the boundary between justified and unjustified belief." —Sam Harris, New Yo...
The Invisible Gorilla: How Our Intuitions Deceive Us
NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER • Our minds don’t work the way we think they do. Two renowned psychologists explain how and why our intuitions...
eBay marketplace picks
Marketplace Samples
Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.
Selected fromUFO poster oneBay.co.uk.
Current eBay listing
FS02 VINTAGE UFO FLYING SAUCERS COMIC ADVERTISING A4 POSTER PRINT
Current eBay listing
VINTAGE UFO FLYING SAUCERS COMIC ADVERTISING A2 POSTER PRINT
Endnotes
1.
Source: peacocktv.com
Link:https://www.peacocktv.com/watch-online/tv/unidentified-with-demi-lovato/7012570413857604112/seasons/1/episodes/the-star-people-episode-2/07d9feff-d34b-382b-babe-fc1b852995cd
2.
Source: breitbart.com
Title: Watch: Demi Lovato Serenades Ghost Suffering from Sexism-Induced Trauma
Link:https://www.breitbart.com/entertainment/2021/12/24/demi-lovato-serenades-woke-ghost-suffering-from-trauma-due-to-sexism/
Source snippet
Watch: Demi Lovato Serenades Ghost Suffering from Sexism-Induced TraumaDecember 24, 2021...
Published: December 24, 2021
3.
Source: people.com
Link:https://people.com/demi-lovato-was-so-stoned-sang-to-traumatized-ghost-11809242
Source snippet
The show, which aired on Peacock, chronicles Lovato's explorations into UFOs and the paranormal alongside friends Mathew Scott Montgomery...
4.
Source: peacocktv.com
Link:https://www.peacocktv.com/watch-online/tv/unidentified-with-demi-lovato/7012570413857604112
5.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Demi Lovato Performed For GHOSTS & Internet REACTS!
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NfHbAB8tFEs
Source snippet
Unidentified with Demi Lovato | Official Trailer | Peacock Original...
6.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Unidentified with Demi Lovato | Official Trailer | Peacock Original
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUb0U_U3vOE
Source snippet
Paranormal investigators share their stories from Vulture City...
7.
Source: imdb.com
Link:https://www.imdb.com/title/tt14629712/episodes/
Source snippet
Unidentified with Demi Lovato (TV Series 2021) - Episode list - IMDb...
8.
Source: standard.co.uk
Title: Demi Lovato
Link:https://www.standard.co.uk/culture/music/demi-lovato-its-not-that-deep-review-b1254251.html
Source snippet
It's Not That Deep review: dance-pop bangers that peer into the soul | The StandardOctober 24, 2025 — DEMI LOVATO - IT'S NOT THAT DEEP RE...
Published: October 24, 2025
9.
Source: filmthreat.com
Title: Star People | Film Threat
Link:https://filmthreat.com/reviews/star-people-review/
10.
Source: rottentomatoes.com
Title: Star People | Rotten Tomatoes
Link:https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/star_people
11.
Source: tvguide.com
Link:https://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/unidentified-with-demi-lovato/episodes/1000961588/
12.
Source: rt.com
Title: Demi Lovato sings to ghost to heal its ‘trauma’ from sexism — RT Entertainment
Link:https://www.rt.com/pop-culture/543687-demi-lovato-sings-ghost/
13.
Source: commonsensemedia.org
Title: Unidentified With Demi Lovato
Link:https://www.commonsensemedia.org/tv-reviews/unidentified-with-demi-lovato
14.
Source: rottentomatoes.com
Link:https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/star_people/reviews?type=user
Additional References
15.
Source: independent.co.uk
Link:https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/reviews/demi-lovato-review-its-not-that-deep-charli-b2850691.html
Source snippet
October 24, 2025 — DEMI LOVATO REVIEW, IT’S NOT THAT DEEP: PLENTY OF HUMAN HEART PUMPING BENEATH THE BANGERS If the hooks and vocal commi...
Published: October 24, 2025
16.
Source: timeout.com
Link:https://www.timeout.com/london/theatre/ghost-stories-review
Source snippet
September 22, 2025 — Image: Ghost Stories, Lyric Hammersmith 2019Photograph: Chris Payne Review GHOST STORIES 3 out of 5 stars Jeremy Dys...
Published: September 22, 2025
17.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Demi Lovato Woke Up To 3 Extraterrestrial Beings In Their Room
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lISczc-u9wo
Source snippet
Demi Lovato sings to ghost Carmen Unidentified Demi Sings Skyscraper to an Extraterrestrial Entity | Unidentified with Demi Lovato...
18.
Source: youtube.com
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnfXeffcdCM
Source snippet
Demi Lovato Performed For GHOSTS & Internet REACTS...
19.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Paranormal investigators share their stories from Vulture City
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lv4m6zhwHok
Source snippet
Demi Lovato Woke Up To 3 Extraterrestrial Beings In Their Room...
20.
Source: hiptoro.com
Link:https://www.hiptoro.com/p/demi-lovato-helps-ghost-overcome-sexism-by-singing/
21.
Source: rottentomatoes.com
Link:https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/unidentified_with_demi_lovato/s01/e02
22.
Source: rottentomatoes.com
Link:https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/unidentified_with_demi_lovato/s01/e02/cast-and-crew
23.
Source: thedailybeast.com
Title: Demi Lovato Goes Full Tin Foil Hat With ‘Unidentified.’ And It’s a Joy to Watch
Link:https://www.thedailybeast.com/demi-lovato-goes-full-tin-foil-hat-with-unidentified-and-its-a-joy-to-watch/
24.
Source: watch.plex.tv
Title: tv Where to Watch Unexplained: Caught on Camera • Season 2 Full Episodes Online
Link:https://watch.plex.tv/en-GB/show/unexplained-caught-on-camera/season/2